Emergence

Emergence is a concept in systems theory, philosophy, science, and art that, in it's simplest form, can be summarized as sometimes the whole is greater than the sum of the parts. However, in it's most complicated forms we find our understanding of reality breaking down as the methods of scientific inquiry and our Heuristics for constructing a coherent world fall apart.

We experience emergent properties and behaviors every day when we turn on the lights, admire the sunrise, or just open our eyes, because these things depend on phenomena like conductivity, beauty, and consciousness.

These are emergent phenomena:

Comlex Systems cannot always be summarized by adding up the characteristics of their components, they exhibit emergent properties or behaviors which their components do not have on their own.

↳ From the source
“A system is more than the sum of its parts. It may exhibit adaptive, dynamic, goal- seeking, self- preserving, and sometimes evolutionary behavior.”
Cause and Effect Breaks Down

Emergent phenomena present a real challenge to our coherence of our world, because we cannot draw causal lines from the components to the properties or behavior. It's difficult to grapple with interactions which you cannot understand through reductionist cause and effect, so we gloss over it or seek causation where none exists.

↳ From the source
“We are evidently ready from birth to have impressions of causality, which do not depend on reasoning about patterns of causation. They are products of System 1.”
But Really, What Is It?

Emergent properties and behaviors are incredibly difficult to explain and study. Few experts agree on the words let alone the reality behind the phenomena. The usual reductionist approaches of science don't work, and you quickly end up debating metaphysics.

Philosophers differentiate between "weak" and "strong" emergence. Weak emergence is the idea that properties emerge from very complex systems but they are connected to their components. If we had perfect information we could calculate the weakly emergent property. Strong emergence is the idea that the properties could not be deduced even with perfect information, because it is wholly separate from the lower level components.

With Systems Theory we might surmise that sufficiently complex Self-Organizing Systems are the source of emergent phenomena, and find ourselves analyzing the fractal geometry of snowflakes.

↳ From the source
“Self- organization is such a common property, particularly of living systems, that we take it for granted. If we didn’t, we would be dazzled by the unfolding systems of our world. And if we weren’t nearly blind to the property of self- organization, we would do better at encouraging, rather than destroying, the self- organizing capacities of the systems of which we are a part.”
It Matters

We don't understand emergence, but it matters that we try. Our lack of understanding is at the root of debates in human rights, animal rights, and AI Safety. Having a better understanding of emergence could lead to scientific advancements in Materials Science and healthcare. The benefits are immeasurable.

Reference Notes1 book · 2 links
  1. Wikipedia: Emergenceen.wikipedia.org
  2. p. 76
Keep exploring

The rest of the garden is one click away

Every published note connects back to a topic map. Start there, or reach out if you want to talk any of this through.

Back to the Knowledge Garden
KNOWLEDGE GARDEN — PRIVATE NOTE

This note is not part of Kyle's published work. His knowledge garden is large — most of it stays private, shared only in conversation. If you want to explore this idea further, reach out or schedule time.